10 Best Pizza Places in Scottsdale, AZ (2026)

Venezia's New York Style Pizzeria

The undisputed king of New York-style pizza in the Valley

Multiple Scottsdale locations

Ask anyone in the Phoenix area where to get the best New York-style pizza and Venezia's is the answer that comes up more than any other. The slices are massive, thin, foldable, and have that perfect ratio of sauce to cheese to crust that NY-style purists demand. Multiple Reddit threads have crowned Venezia's the best pizza in the Valley, and their Scottsdale locations are always busy for good reason. The garlic knots are addictive and the chicken parm sub is excellent too. It's not fancy, it's not artisan, it's just really damn good New York pizza.

Best New York-style in the ValleyMassive foldable slicesLegendary garlic knots

Visit Website View in Directory

Craft 64

Artisan wood-fired pizza with local craft beer in Old Town

Old Town Scottsdale

Craft 64 is the artisan pizza spot in Old Town Scottsdale that beer lovers and pizza purists both adore. They brew their own beer on-site and the wood-fired pizzas are made with serious attention to quality ingredients. The dough is fermented for days, the toppings are locally sourced, and the pies come out of the wood-fired oven with that perfect char and chew. The Scottsdale location on Main Street has a great patio. It's casual enough for a family dinner but the quality is high enough for a food-focused date night. The IPA pairs perfectly with the pepperoni pie.

House-brewed craft beerWood-fired artisan piesOld Town Main Street patio

Visit Website View in Directory

Yo Pauly's

Authentic East Coast pizza with huge portions and attitude

McCormick Ranch, Scottsdale

Yo Pauly's is the kind of pizza joint that feels transported straight from the East Coast. The New York-style pies are massive, the portions are generous, and the attitude is 100% authentic. Reddit users consistently recommend Yo Pauly's alongside Venezia's as the top tier of NY-style pizza in Scottsdale. The cheese slices are a perfect late-night option, and their specialty pies show range beyond the basics. The McCormick Ranch location has become a neighborhood staple. If you're from the East Coast and missing home, Yo Pauly's will ease the pain.

East Coast authentic vibeMassive NY-style piesReddit-recommended alongside Venezia's

Visit Website View in Directory

Strad Pizza

Newer arrival making serious waves in the Scottsdale pizza scene

North Scottsdale

Strad Pizza is one of the newer additions to the Scottsdale pizza scene and it's already generating serious buzz. Located on North Scottsdale Road, they serve well-crafted pies with quality ingredients and dough that shows real skill. Multiple Reddit threads mention Strad as a rising contender in the Scottsdale pizza rankings. The menu includes both traditional and creative options, and the execution on both is impressive. The space is casual and family-friendly. Keep an eye on this one because it's building a loyal following fast.

Rising pizza contenderQuality dough and ingredientsBuilding a cult following

Visit Website View in Directory

Grimaldi's Pizzeria

Brooklyn-born coal-fired pizza institution

Multiple Scottsdale locations

Grimaldi's started under the Brooklyn Bridge in 1990 and their Arizona locations bring that same coal-fired pizza tradition to the desert. The coal-fired ovens produce a distinctly charred, thin crust that's different from standard New York-style. The margherita pizza is a classic and the white pie with fresh ricotta is excellent. Yes, it's a chain now, but the Scottsdale locations maintain quality and the pizza is genuinely good. The no-slices policy (whole pies only) keeps the quality consistent. A solid, reliable option that delivers every time.

Coal-fired brick ovenBrooklyn pizza heritageWhole pies only for quality

Visit Website View in Directory

Federal Pizza

Neighborhood pizza joint with creative toppings and great beer

Phoenix (near Scottsdale border)

Federal Pizza sits right on the Phoenix/Scottsdale border and it's worth the short drive for any Scottsdale resident. The wood-fired pizzas here are creative without being weird. The 'Notorious P.I.G.' with prosciutto and the verde pie with green chiles are local favorites. The beer selection is excellent with a rotating tap list that showcases Arizona craft breweries. The space is casual and laid-back with a neighborhood feel. It's the kind of place where you can show up in flip-flops, order a great pie and a local IPA, and have a perfect low-key dinner.

Creative but grounded toppingsExcellent Arizona craft beer selectionNeighborhood vibe

Visit Website View in Directory

Nookies Pizza

Neighborhood spot with huge slices and a loyal following

South Scottsdale

Nookies is the kind of neighborhood pizza place that builds an army of loyal regulars. The slices are big, the cheese pull is real, and the prices are fair. It's nothing fancy and that's the point. They do classic pizza well, day in and day out. The pepperoni and the supreme are the go-to orders. Delivery is solid and reliable, which matters more than people think. Nookies is the pizza place Scottsdale locals order from on a random Tuesday when they just want good pizza without overthinking it.

Big slices, fair pricesLoyal local followingReliable delivery

Visit Website View in Directory

Pomo Pizzeria

Certified Neapolitan pizza with imported Italian ingredients

Old Town Scottsdale

Pomo is the place for Neapolitan pizza purists in Scottsdale. They're certified by the Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana, meaning their ingredients, dough, and technique meet strict Italian standards. The Capri wood-fired oven was imported from Naples, the San Marzano tomatoes come from the slopes of Mount Vesuvius, and the result is a pizza that could hold its own in Italy. The margherita is perfect in its simplicity. If you appreciate the craft of traditional Neapolitan pizza, Pomo is the only real answer in Scottsdale.

Certified Neapolitan pizzaImported Italian ingredientsOven shipped from Naples

Visit Website View in Directory

Joe's New York Pizza

Late-night slice shop perfect for post-bar pit stops

Old Town Scottsdale

Joe's on Shoeman Lane in Old Town is the late-night pizza hero that Old Town needs and deserves. When the bars start letting out and you need a slice, Joe's is there. The New York-style slices are big, hot, and exactly what you want at that hour. Is it the best pizza in Scottsdale by food critic standards? Maybe not. Is it the most important pizza in Scottsdale at 1 AM? Absolutely. Beyond the late-night crowd, the daytime slices are genuinely solid too. It's a quick, no-nonsense New York slice experience in the heart of Old Town.

Late-night Old Town essentialQuick counter-service slicesPost-bar hero

Visit Website View in Directory

Spinato's Pizzeria

Valley institution for over 50 years with gluten-free expertise

Multiple Scottsdale-area locations

Spinato's has been serving the Valley since 1974, making it one of the longest-running pizza operations in the area. They've earned special recognition for their gluten-free pizza, which is legitimately one of the best GF options in the state. The regular pizza is excellent too with a style that's uniquely Spinato's (not quite NY, not quite Neapolitan). The family recipes have been refined over five decades, and the consistency shows. For families, especially those dealing with dietary restrictions, Spinato's has been a lifesaver and a favorite for generations.

Serving the Valley since 1974Best gluten-free pizza in AZFamily recipes, five decades

Visit Website View in Directory